Weir should undergo gender testing: sports broadcaster
2010 GAMES / Quebec gays file complaint with Canadian Broadcast Standards Council
Tamara Letkeman / Vancouver / Tuesday, February 23, 2010
Share |

RDS BROADCASTER SAYS WEIR SETS BAD EXAMPLE. 'Every little boy should be so lucky as to turn into me,' says Weir, seen here at Skate America in Everett, WA.
(www.sundancechannel.com/Be Good Johnny Weir series)
A Quebec gay rights group has filed a complaint with the Canadian Broadcast Standards Council over comments made about Olympic figure skater Johnny Weir on the French-language sports channel RDS.

On Feb 21, the Quebec Council of Gays and Lesbians (CQGL) launched its complaint demanding an apology from RDS sportscasters Claude Mailhot and Alain Goldberg for homophobic comments the pair made on-air about Weir, an American skater known for his flashy performance style and flamboyant fashion sense.

Mailhot, speaking for himself and Goldberg, apologized for their "tactless comments on the appearance and manner of a figure skater" during a later broadcast. But Steve Foster, CEO of the CQGL, says the apology is insufficient.

"We were not satisfied with the apology given by Claude Mailhot because it was regarding [Weir's] clothing and appearance, but our main subject was homophobic terms used during the show."

During coverage of the men's figure skating competition last week, Mailhot asked Goldberg if he thought that Weir, who came in sixth, lost points because of his costume — a low-cut, pink-and-black outfit with ruffles — and his body language.

Goldberg replied that Weir was setting a "bad example" for other male skaters. "They'll think all the boys who skate will end up like him," he said.

The pair also wisecracked that Weir should undergo gender testing and should compete in women's events.

"We don't know if Johnny Weir is gay or not and for us it's not important," Foster says. "What is important is that nobody deserves to be treated like that in the public space."

If the RDS gives the CQGL a real apology, Foster says the organization will accept it and take no further action. "But if they don't apologize properly, we just wish the commission will give them blame for their actions on the program."

Pamela Mollica, spokesperson for RDS through Canada's Olympic Broadcast Media Consortium, did not return requests for an interview by press time.

In response to the incident, the RDS has issued a statement declaring, "All discriminatory statements, or those appearing discriminatory, have neither a place in society nor in media."

Weir's publicists did not respond to requests for an interview by press time either. But Pink News, a European online gay news service, reported Feb 23 that Weir, who refuses to publicly reveal his sexual orientation, shrugged off the comment on gender testing.

"Every little boy should be so lucky as to turn into me. And that's all I have to say about that."


Share |


Reader Comments


 
CQGL & Olympic Athlete Johnny Weir
I'm very proud of the Québec Council for Gays and Lesbians (CQGL)for reacting normally to homophobic remarks aimed at an Olympic Athlete in Vancouver. These commentators, as well as the two really weird ones from Australia, lack the professionalism required to comment on the competitions Olympic Athletes who strive to make the World a better place through the values of Excellence, Respect and Friendship. Johnny Weir has a family who loves him just as he is; he has loved ones and friends who are deeply offended by the homophobic wisecracks of the commentators, and he has thousands of fans who know how to support him. This young man has been practicing his sport, and at the most ungodly hours, since he was a kid, rather than developing an ordinary social life of his own. He is an exceptional and highly talented Olympic Athlete and he deserves "professional" commentators while he is competing. RDS needs to apologize, and the two from Australia's Channel Nine should be sacked at once. To say that Johnny Weir "doesn't leave much in the locker room"..."nor in the closet" on the air is one derogatory homophobic statement after another and they have no place in Canada's Winter Olympic Games 2010. Canada is a country where Gay Rights are Human Rights, and if the Australian media doesn't give a toss for Human Rights, then what's the difference between them and Buhati & Ssempa in Uganda, or the persecution and execution of gays in Iran? Seriously. The Québec Council for Gays and Lesbians reacted normally. Canada knows very well that we, the gay community of Canada, would not have come such a long way without the consistent and relentless efforts of French-Canadians to identify and denounce homophobia because we know that homophobia leads to violence, and too often to deadly violence. Moreover, Johnny Weir is an excellent role model for young American athletes of all kinds. He is an Olympic Athlete; enough said.
Jean-Paul, Bathurst N.B.
02/23/10 9:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Weir's mystique
http://www.xtra.ca/blog/montreal/post/2010/02/22/the-Johnny-Weir-Mystique.aspx
Lina Harper, Montreal QC
02/24/10 11:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
great skater Weir out as gender-bending queer
Johnny Weir was most eloquent (and gracious) yesterday when asked about the attacks on him as a fem/queer skater. He said he is a role model for those who want to be themselves. While he didn't "come out" as gay, he came out as a human being who sense of identity is not conventional. He tests the boundaries of gender--a very fem guy--and defends his right to do so. A great skater and performer, Weir deserves plaudits for his defense of his gender-bending. "coming out" can be a difficult process, and especially so for athletes who make more money from endorsements where being straight is more lucrative. Mark Tewskbury in his autobiograohy "Inside Out" tells of the painful difficulties of his long coming out process which only happened after he left sports and endorsements. He is frank about the material advantages of appearing straight for endorsements ( he had the all-Canadian meat industry one and had a "beard" or female fake girlfriend to show he was straight). But this is a new generation and Johnny Weir is emblematic of one aspect of it. In my view Weir is very courageous and a role model as he is--an gender-bending great skater. It seems there is more ways than one of being "out". (It would be hard to say Weir is in the closet, eh, even thougn he didn't say he was a practising homo?). (His Poker Face Lady Gaga routine was stunning and he is being poker face re his sexual preference but not his gender.) To each his own (in their way of coming out) . (Ditto for John Baird who is out to gay friends and others but not publically out. That, in the end, is his choice, as it was for the late Ian Scott. We cannot impose standards for each one's painful and unique outing process.
james Dubro, toronto ontario
02/25/10 8:34 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.