The village tune-up
Julia Gonsalves / Toronto / Thursday, September 09, 2010
Share |

What are the essentials of a good queer neighbourhood? What would attract more queer Toronto people who feel they belong in the Village, as well as those who currently feel they don’t?
 
I remember when I first started coming here. It was only at night, and these small little city blocks felt huge and alive. It seemed like a magical oasis back when I was coming out.
 
I hadn’t yet learned why it felt like a refuge to this light-skinned, middle-class lesbian but might not feel that way to someone else. 
 
I felt I fit in here at first, back when the world was, for me, divided into gay and un-gay. It was clearly gay here, and that was enough to separate the Village from the rest of my life — suburban, Catholic and definitively un-gay. But as time went on, I began to see the neighbourhood’s underside: how male-dominated everything was, how cisgendered everything was, how superficial things were. 
 
Over time I felt like I fit less, and my lovely oasis became my Pete’s Dragon, my Polkaroo, the rose-coloured glasses that didn’t fit me anymore. Here are 10 things that I think would bring back some of that magic in a real, lasting way. 
 
1. A queer-run clothing store that sells boy clothes that actually fit those of us who weren’t born boys but now want to look like them. Especially those of us who don’t fit a men’s small. An owner who gets that sometimes, yes, you actually want to look flat and hipless and like you rolled out of bed and put on your brother’s shirt. It would be equipped, of course, with change rooms with mirrors on the inside, and salespeople who let you come to them and only offered opinions when asked.
 
2. A movie theatre with clean seats and popcorn and organic lemonade. A theatre that screens commercial, local and independent movies interchangeably, including kids’ movies and teen movies, episodes of new queer shows and back episodes of Xena: Warrior Princess.
 
3. An independent coffee shop where a coffee is still less than two dollars, where you can borrow Scrabble boards and there is enough room between tables for a stroller, so you don’t have to wake your sleeping baby to get a break. 
 
4. A neighbourhood policy on highchairs in restaurants — meaning establishments must have them, because queer people have kids too, and that doesn’t make us un-sexy or bad for business.
 
5. A LATE-NIGHT CUPCAKE SHOP. They have these things in New York. I have never been so excited about standing in a line to eat something in my life. A frosted, freshly baked vanilla cupcake at three in the morning is absolute heaven. Heaven!
 
6. A big row of bike racks on the southwest corner of Church and Wellesley — maybe like the ones in front of the AGO but cock-shaped? Something amusing and functional that would prevent me from having to ask the TD security guard to watch my bike when the posts are full. The bike rack would be the new water cooler, the new place to gather and chat. 
 
7. A bike repair shop — some-thing small, where you have the option of paying extra if you want to be taught how to do it yourself. It is about time our community got engaged in a health-promotion strategy that isn’t about sexual health (although, of course, those are needed too), or about mental health (obviously just as necessary) but just about getting physically active, for the sake of feeling good. 
 
8. A recreation space that isn’t for pool, darts, bingo or a bathhouse. Levelling a piece of Cawthra Park would work, or building a climbing wall in the Beer Store parking lot. This would be a first step in creating a positive, designated space for youth — something that is completely lacking in our community right now.
 
9. A new and used music store that, like the movie theatre, sells stuff by commercial, local and independent artists. One that highlights new releases with a queer slant and keeps alive the old Phranc and Ani albums. One with a patio for local bands to play to the street.
 
10. Pedestrian days in the Village. This would be the perfect place for a weekly car-free experience, with lots of room to mix and mingle, support local stores, use sidewalk chalk, worry less about your kids and build comfortable, connected community. 
 
People say this neighbourhood is dying, that queers are scattering and not so interested anymore in having a home base. I think there will always be a need for the Village, and that it needs to keep adapting to promote greater diversity, acceptance, health and well-being. That’s speaking as if the Village is an entity in itself, and not just an extension of the people who inhabit it. 
 
So, it’s us who need to keep adapting. Socially and financially, we need to employ strategies that encourage people to get invested in being here, and to see the Village as less of an attraction or a cheap hotel and more of a neighbourhood, or a home. 


Share |


Reader Comments


 
why so full of hate?
how male-dominated everything was, how cisgendered everything was, how superficial things were. -- You are an obnoxious bigot. If someone male and gay said that the Village was ruined by lamebrained trendoid gender twerp women complaining about asinine issues like boys clothes for them, you would freak out and scream Human rights transphobia. What is the difference in your hatred??? YOU are what ruined the Village, Missy. Look in a mirror and check your own trans privilege and bigotry at the neighbourhood entrance. btw middle aged women getting jiggy with gender and hating gay cis men is so two years ago, madame. What a provincial joke!
sick of this whiner!, toronto ON
09/10/10 12:59 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
There's nothing wrong
With her criticism, apart from being too hippyish, organic lemonade really? She's making a valid point that the village is dying because it is too male dominated and there are few young people moving and choosing to live there. I've only been there a few times to visit but I've found the place very exclusive, Only certain kinds of gay men are accepted. If you happen to be too straight-acting people don't treat you very well. Also, you really don't need a ghetto anymore. Honestly I've found the scene in Edmonton far more welcoming friendly and inclusive to GLBT people than Toronto's. All of the colours of the Rainbow are there and much more integrated with each other.
Mike, Edmonton but now Barrie Alberta but now Ontario
09/10/10 6:05 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Let's face it
Gay men and queer whatevers are not meant to co-mingle. Let's agree to meet once a year at the main pride parade (after the various queers of colour/femi-nazi/tranny separatist parties) and then you stay the fuck out of the neighbourhood village that gay men built and paid for with our blood and cash for the next 12 months. P.S. Those bath houses that you dismiss like non-organic lemonade are pillars of the village and literally exist built on gay men's blood, sweat and tears.
GAY NOT QUEER, Toronto ON
09/10/10 6:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
come on Edmontoon
Mike, a couple of tourist visits to a city hardly lend credence to a complete socio analysis of a neighbourhood! What a PC nerd. Toronto is "diverse" 24-7 as everyday life. Setting up a cute little every body is included clubhouse is so 1994 here. So speak of what you know!
lived here all my life Mary, toronto ON
09/10/10 6:52 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Fences make good neighbours
If lesbians and trans people dislike gay men, they should stay away from them, rather than trash them in columns in Xtra. I have no problem with separatism within the community. If Lesbians have their own march at Pride, gay men should have their own march at Pride. Fences make good neighbours.
Steve, Toronto Ontario
09/10/10 9:22 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Fences are indeed good
I agree with Steve, because if some people do no like the neighborhood then build another one. Please. Don't whine. Do you OWN thing! MAn! Come on!
Abdullah, Leamington ON
09/11/10 12:41 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
bigotry in boys clothing
This is like a breath of fresh air to me a gay male separatist. After years of trans and genderqueer tyranny and the revenge attacks on "cis" (born with penis and balls) gay men (men born with penis and balls who love and fuck other men born with penis and balls) and the silencing of any response to this, Xtra is actually allowing this bullshit to be slapped down and called out for the bigotry it is. Reverse oppression by people who feel they were victims is one thing. Man and fag bashing by trans and gender people is over. Read these letters and realize that not being able to play in a sandbox custom made for you (with boy clothes in every store) is childish bigoted WHINING! Divisive, obnoxious and OVER! Retire to a genderqueer commune in the woods and burn gay cis men in effigy as your enemies. Ding dong the genderqueer witch at last is dead!
gay is not queer and never will be, toronto ON
09/11/10 9:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
By the way Mary.
Ya know Mary, I wouldn't call little isolated ethnic bubbles throughout a city, ''diverse'' and by the way the gay ghetto is so 1983. Get with the times... You'd think that all of you prejudiced old fags would have moved on and at least tried to integrate with everyone else, Including trans people, lesbians and even straight people. I'm glad this wave of the Gay rights movement is going the way of the dinosaurs. What a bunch of prejudiced old queens, You've become the thing you hated and fought against.
far away, Barrie Ontario
09/11/10 5:46 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
beige pots calling kettles black
Barrie Fairy, the fumes from Kempenfelt Bay must be choking your Queer brain. The Village is nothing like it was in 1983 -- I lived there then. Did you? All the "old queens" have actually left and assimilated into the larger city (except some gay seniors who find safety in one neighbourhood). Twerpy queer nerds from Barrie and chip on their shoulder suburban lesbians pretending to be gender bois like the author are now the "Village". Diversity is everywhere (how could you know if you do not live here!) in a way that Barrie or is it still called Klantown could not know. And all groups have their own places and spaces both shared and separate. Forced mingling is so Barrie. It is not prejudice. It is life. And you have no idea what we fought for or you would not make such childish and ignorant comments. Enjoy Queer Barrie as long as you're not Asian fishermen, eh.
get off my lawn, yawney, toronto ON
09/12/10 10:02 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
A Starting Point
Although your LIST is interesting, and some of it I agree with, I know of a better starting point from which the Village could begin from. CLEAN THE BLOODY PLACE UP ! LOL ! I swear, T.O.'s Gay Village is FILTHY. For the life of me, I can't understand why the area's BIA doesn't put in place a clean-up program - staring with power-washing the sidewalks, permanently removing ALL posters that cover every poll / post / wall around the place, and setting standards for each business relating to the cleanliness of their windows / store-fronts (ie: entranceways). This list is a good starting point from which community pride of our Village could start from. I guess the guy that heads the BIA (the same business owner (ICE CREAM wink wink) that has made 100's of thousands of dollars from the gay community over the years yet has NO gay employees on the payroll) isn't much interested in what's best for the Village - unless it serves his purposes.
Mr. Clean, T.O. ONT
09/12/10 1:14 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
This just in: not all young queers like clubs.
I totally agree that the Village (nay, all of the downtown core) needs to diversify its late-night entertainment offerings to satisfy the needs of city-goers like me who find no allure in the club scene. A venue with board games is a FABULOUS idea, as are accessible bowling alleys, karaoke bars, and arcade halls (remember those?). In fact, with the opening of that board games cafe in The Annex last month, the future of Toronto as an entertainment centre never looked so promising -- or so sexy!
Martin Otarola, Toronto Ontario
09/14/10 8:53 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
I Second Cleaning the Bloody Place Up!!
Julia's suggestions are commendable, but completely unrealistic. Independent coffee shops, theatres, and record stores haven't existed in Toronto since 1995. Okay besides the few in Kensington or the odd little boutique here and there, none of them are very successful. Toronto's too commercial for anything countercultural to make a splash in the local economy. Also Julia, highchairs? Really? For every child that visits the Village there are 10 crackheads, 10 hoodlums, and a variety of other weirdos. To make the neighbourhood kid-friendly, you'd basically need build a wall and put up check-points. If I had kids, this is the last neighbourhood I'd choose to raise them. More to Mr. Clean's point, it's nasty. The place needs a good scrub and residents and tourists alike need to take more pride in the streets, rather than you know, piss all over them.
Ryan, Toronto ON
09/14/10 10:50 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
sick of the angry bitches
wow some of you must have some serious resentment and anger to get so pissed off at such an innocent article! what, do you just sit around all day writing rude pissy comments on websites over nothing...get a life...and a job! good article, valid points, the village needs a serious overhaul.
jay, toronto on
09/15/10 5:57 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The author is right
i have two kids of my own and my partner and I often talk about how the village needs to be far more kid friendly, no restaurants have high chairs and the waiters generally dislike it when we're around, many of our friends with kids also have this issue. I like the idea of having more physical activity space and opportunities for healthy engagement. It's also true that the village is more male centric, I'm not sure why this would make anybody a 'bigot' or 'hater of gay cis men' for pointing it out, it's just a reality...a reflection of the rest of society. and yes it needs to be cleaned up!
sash, toronto ontario
09/15/10 7:05 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
complicit in the hate
jay -- some readers are sick to death of the anti-gay and anti-male hatred of writers like this person. That is enough to cause such a reaction. You obviously feel as she does and hate as well or you would accept the feelings as legit. Why are YOU filled with such contempt and indifference to other people's oppression, hmm??? sash -- 2 things. The comment that the village was male and "cis" was presented as BAD by the author -- something to change. Prejudice much? And maybe you could get rid of some of those horrible faggot cis men by turning Steamworkd bathhouse on Church into a Chuckie Cheese. Women and children only. No cis men allowed. Happy now, bigot?
sick of the hate, toronto ON
09/15/10 7:17 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
RE: complicit in the hate
@Sick of the hate: I think you are mistaken in thinking the author is misandrous. It's true that the entire movement has focused on men, rather than women. When people think "Gay", one imagines a stereotypical, gay man. Not usually women, trans people, or intersexed individuals. And even now there seems to be a plethora of activities and businesses directed towards the male crowd (after all, isn't it usually white males who possess more money?) There are not many things for women and cis people, and I agree that we need to be more inclusive of OUR minorities in the community. You sound like a misogynist.
Brad, Toronto ON
09/15/10 11:06 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
take your self-shame and shove it
And you sound like an ass. It's called real life, platypus. It ain't a day care for victims. Brad, are your self-shamed by your cis white privilege? Sweat and tears and beatings got white gay men where we are. Other groups are perfectly free to do the same thing over 40 years as well. If you want privilege handed to you on a platter, then give your possessions to the Whiners Club.(FYI, Most intersexed people do NOT include themselves with LBGTQ!, jerk!).
sick of the crybabies, toronto ON
09/16/10 10:35 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The article is ridiculous
This debate reminds me of the attempts by some queer females to gain access to gay men's bath houses. Businesses along the streets in the gay men's village exist because that's what the market will bear. Socialism never works. If the market demanded restaurants with high chairs then that is what would be available. Gay men who make up the largest clientele of restaurant patrons in that particular neighbourhood don't want to listen to someone's screaming kid while eating. Therefore the restaurants don't offer high chairs. You have an entire city full of family restaurants to take kids. Queer females should back off.
GAY NOT QUEER, Toronto On
09/16/10 11:14 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
RE: Take your shame and shove it
@Sick of the crybabies: Wow, great argument! Clearly you aren't the one so full of hate. Do you really think gay men are the only ones who suffered beatings, getting evicted, being fired, and being harassed? I remember reading about several lesbians being beaten for being lesbians. Trans people are constantly being attacked, and are still being murdered frequently! Not to mention that trans people and women were with gay men in the fight for our rights! They deserve just as much as we do! Gay men didn't do all the work; they just took the glory and forgot about their comrades!
Brad, Toronto ON
09/16/10 11:52 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
THANK YOU JULIA GONSALVEZ
for finally talking about the need for more youth friendly space and activities in the gay village. I'm 17 years old and I don't really have anywhere to hang out there and would love positive designated space for us. There's the 519 but there's only so long i can loiter in the foyer before i start feeling silly, and the youth group there is for trans youth so i can't go. The area is full of bars, that i cant even get into. I would LOVE a music store, and a movie theater would be awesome, and the recreation space would be really great! i think the cupcake shop is the best idea mmmm cupcakes. I think there should also be a central spot, like a main meeting place outdoors with a fountain and benches and stuff. anyways thanks for speaking up for us!
jordan, toronto ontario
09/16/10 1:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
inclusion
I am a gay man with a two year old who also has trouble navigating church and wellesley with a child in tow. I think it's extremely important to integrate our children and families into the hood even if we don't live there, especially us daddys who are not often visible. It does nothing for us as a community for us to stay away even if businesses and some community members are resistant to it. The community includes us so we should be included in the community.
gay daddy, toronto on
09/16/10 2:32 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Don't blame gays
Queers tend to be socialistic and anti-capitalist. Therefore they tend not to operate for profit businesses. This helps result in a lack of spaces for queers in the community. Gay men on the other hand tend not to shy away from extracting money from each other. Whether it's food, alcohol, sex or anything else, gay men show the entrepreneurial spirit. The result is plenty of options for gay men in almost any large city. Who's fault is this? Queers need to stop whining and expecting others to change things for them. A gay man is not going to open that vegan cafe for you...unless queers are ready to spend big bucks.
Let the Market Decide, Toronto On
09/16/10 3:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Well now...
@Don't blame gays It is worth noting that the "socialistic and anti-capitalist" "queers" were at the forefront at fighting for gay and lesbian rights when it was very unfashionable to do so and most bars catering to gay mails were owned by predatory straights. It is only when it was safer to do so that all of those capitalistic loving gay guys came to the fore, enabled by all of those "socialistic" activists that came before... Make no mistake, it is not the right wing which supported this fight for gay rights by the left...The right was too busy shilling for theri corporate masters and cozying up the evangelical christians.
pjr, Toronto ON
09/16/10 5:24 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Tune it up
I think it's natural instinct to want to fit in and it's understandably disappointing when you don't. I feel the same way as the author. When i was first exposed to the village i was in awe, so many people who were out and proud, lgbtq couples holding hands, it was all so new and different. But a few years later and as I spent more time here I saw some of the issues with it. I think you're right that the relevance of a central home base for lgbtq people may be decreasing as lgbtq friendly spots around the city pop up but I think it's still important especially for lgtbq kids looking for a place to be accepted. Like it or not the village is where they go and often their first experince with lgbtq culture. I think we SHOULD be critical of a place that holds such high expectations for our young people and is a representation of our communities and culture to so many. That representation should be representative of the diversity of lgbtq communities. Critical analysis is healthy not hateful and we need to continue to speak out, as this journalist is doing, for positive change within the Church and Wellesley neighbourhood.
Marla, Toronto ON
09/16/10 5:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Cupcakes to Feed the Revolution!
I think that some of the frustration about what gets called whining is this: why should the Village be all things to all people? It basically started as a few gay bars, and gay (yes, mostly white) men moved into the area so they could live, work and socialize in proximity and feel safe. But is isnt' cut in stone. There's room for change, but make it happen. Don't demand that gay white men be less white - we've tried. It doesn't work! Get away from your laptop and open a fucking bar for lesbians of colour, already. If there's a demand for social, commercial spaces for other subsets of the broader gay community, well, rather than bitching, open a business. Just because you are a lesbian who likes cupcakes and is sensitive about the cisgender hegemony etc. doesn't mean the world should revolve around your special needs. Stake out a space and then do your thing. The gay community did it. Italians and Koreans and Chinese didn't whine "Toronto is so white/WASP!" - they staked out space. They bought houses. They opened restaurants and started social clubs. The were active agents of their own future. Get with it, or shut the fuck up already.
Emma Goldperson, Toronto ON
09/16/10 9:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yep
OMG cupcakes!! Calm down, girl- And hey, yo, these comments are gender-craaaaazy! reminds me why that that stupid bitch hit me in the face at goodhandy's a while back- queer people, say it with me, gender- yes, people enjoy them; now can y'all proceed not being crazy? uh huh? would you hit better if you were born a boy? well gee, I don't know, I mean, some fags are built like a brick-shit house- hahahaha- yo Julia's a good columnist tho fo rill-
John, Toronto On
09/17/10 3:39 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Yep
lolz- I mean, is that it, was I "cis"? Is that like "sus" for suspect gay at American pre-schools? Jokes I already pegged this bitch as a member of the bash-back movement- now I hadn't heard about the dreaded "cis" at the time, and well, still have NO IDEA what a "cis" is, is that like I'm my sister, who has 3 kids? super LOLZ! I'll say for the record: a) I was bashed by a t-boy at goodhandy's the same night that Chris Skinner was murdered on Queen street and b) I am still well within the 2 years alotted to me by the crown in which I can sue for torts. (omg- battery is still set at a milli? and negligence for occupier's liability is ever higher, and as an invitee for goodhandy's they're vicariously responsible for the actions of their patrons? 2 million dollars- SUCK THIS
John, Toronto On
09/17/10 4:34 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Adapt Already
I agree with gay daddy- and the article- I'm sick of being overrepresented as a gay man in some arenas yet underrepresented as a gay father in those same arenas. The village, including the people who think it's just fine the way it is, need to get with the times.
Lane, mississauga O
09/17/10 11:22 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.