US journalist grilled at Canadian border
BORDER / Amy Goodman was detained for 90 minutes, questioned about Olympics and told to leave within 48 hours
Jeremy Hainsworth / National / Saturday, November 28, 2009
Share |

An outspoken US journalist is questioning what freedom of the press and speech mean in Canada after she was detained at the border near Vancouver this week.

Amy Goodman says Canadian border agents didn't believe she was visiting Canada to promote her new book and discuss health care, global warming, the global economic meltdown and the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.

Rather, she says, their focus was on what she might say about the 2010 Winter Olympics.

"I was completely shocked," she says.

Goodman was held for 90 minutes at the border as agents grilled her with questions. Goodman says she does not know if she was red-flagged for a search at the border.

Goodman's detention and Olympic-related questioning comes as controversy continues to swirl around what demonstrations will be allowed during the Games.

A city bylaw restricts protests to police-controlled "safe assembly areas." It also bans newspaper boxes such as Xtra West's from areas around Olympic venues. Parts of that bylaw may be rescinded next month after public outcries.

As a result of the detention, Goodman was late for a talk at Vancouver Public Library.

Check it out here.

 


Goodman, host of an American public radio show called Democracy Now, says a border official asked if she intended to talk about the Olympics.

"I said, 'Actually I hadn't thought about talking about the Olympics here,'" Goodman tells Xtra. "He was incredulous. He clearly didn't believe me."

She says her car was searched, books and documents rifled through and a colleague's computers examined.

She said such searches require warrants in the US.

"I don't think it's a good thing for Canada to adopt the worst policies of Homeland Security in the US," she says. "I felt personally violated, professionally violated."

Further, she says, the search of her and her colleagues' possessions violated their right to protect her journalistic sources.

Further, she adds, such tactics put a chill into journalists and prevents them from being able to do their jobs without fear.

"Journalism is so important to the functioning of democracy," she says.

Goodman says she was going to Vancouver to promote her new book, Breaking the Sound Barrier, and to discuss how Canadian Tommy Douglas pioneered Medicare.

STOPPED AT THE BORDER. Amy Goodman is best known as the host of Democracy Now!, a daily, independent news program.
(Karl Gabor/Right Livelihood Award Foundation, rightlivelihood.org)
Before being allowed into Canada, Goodman was photographed and told to be out of the country within two days.

"I wasn't aware I had to have a visa," she says.

The Canada Border Services Agency website says people may be denied entry if they are engaged in subversion or terrorism; have committed war crimes; have serious criminal records; are involved in organized crime or in transnational crimes such as people smuggling, trafficking in people or money laundering; are a health risk; or cannot provide for themselves financially.

Goodman says she does not fit those categories.

Canada Border Services Agency spokesperson Faith St John said she cannot comment on specific cases.

She says anyone entering the country may have their vehicles and goods examined and be referred for a secondary inspection.

"Any referral should not be seen as an accusation of wrongdoing," St John says.

St John says a person may be checked if they have a record of non-compliance at the border, a criminal record or are behaving suspiciously.

Janine Fuller is the manager of Vancouver's Little Sister's bookstore. She's no stranger to heavy-handed tactics at the hands of Customs officials after fighting as far as the Supreme Court of Canada over book seizures.

She says the detaining of Goodman is another call for Canadians to be vigilant about free speech issues around the Olympics.

"What ridiculous waste of taxpayers' money," Fuller says of the detention. "I think they're preparing us for what's to come."

"What does that say about Canada as a society?" Fuller asks.

Further, she asks, "What would Olympic athletes think of this being done in their name?"



Share |


Reader Comments


 
a little bit of power
I think its outrageous the way the CBSA has been conducting itself recently from detaining films to seizing laptops where regular porn was found in the hopes of finding something illegal to this sort of harassment of a journalist for fear she might say something negative about the upcoming Olympics, I used to be an Olympic supporter and hoped Toronto got the games but after what I've been hearing lately I'll be opposing any proposal to bring the games here in the future. I used to work as an assistant immigration officer at Pearson and saw first hand how having a little bit of power turned some folks into raging assholes, not only in Immigration but also in Customs, I got to know a few of them during smoke breaks and we worked nearby, I was told by one customs guy that the Charter of Rights didn't apply to these people since they weren't officially in Canada yet, I'm sure that's not true yet it seemed to be a fairly common belief at least amongst the smokers in Customs. I suspect that having a little bit of power and the belief that those seeking entry to Canada are at their mercy that drives many of these sorts of stories. I got out of Immigration when I found it was starting to bring out parts of my personality I didn't like, yet there were also many long term Immigration officers who were good and decent people, at least as many if not more than those who were total assholes, I imagine it was similar in Customs but they were much more heavily focused on enforcement than Immigration was, at least at the time, this was pre-9/11. I believe we need a civilian agency to oversee the actions of the CBSA and to handle and investigate complaints against them like we do for the cops here in Ontario. They need to be reigned in and reminded constantly of their duties and responsibilities to base enforcement on actual threats to our country instead of controlling what Canadians can or cannot see and hear.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
11/28/09 4:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Visa
She's upset because she didn't know she was required to have a visa? Some people make the effort to learn these things before they travel to a foreign country.
L., Kingston ON
11/28/09 5:29 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Visa not needed
L. - a visa isn't required for Americans to visit Canada, she was upset because she was being treated as if she needed a visa, ie. being photographed and being told to leave within 48hrs, this sort of treatment is very unusual for an American crossing the border to give a talk at a library. Americans only need visas in Canada for working, studying or immigrating, there may have been a case if the CBSA agent considered her talk as work which would've been a huge stretch of the regulations but they would've made that very clear to her instead of focusing on the possibility that she might say something negative about the Olympics and certainly the CBSA spokesperson would've mentioned something about visas if they had felt that was the case which clearly they did not quite correctly. Some people make the effort to learn these things before criticizing others traveling to a foreign country.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
11/28/09 6:28 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
@$%&*! the Olympics!
I am *so* sick of all this Olympic$ bullshit. We're losing schools, hospitals, government offices, etc. in the Interior, but there's still bajillions of dollars for the Olympic$ and the scumbag developers that backed that drunk-driving asshole, Campbell. Well, Vancouverites got what they wanted (although they didn't have the guts to let the REST of the province vote on this pork-fest boondoggle). Well, they're welcome to it, and I hope it bankrupts the damn city. I hope there's constant RAIN, and the gawddamn whole corporate-whore, juice-monkey greed-fest gets washed out in a sea of red ink. Fuck the Olympic$ and fuck Gordon Campbell. (And before anyone leaps up to exclaim, "But Glen Clark started the bid on the Games!"... yeah, well fuck him too!) I hope there are losses so massive that the next person who *mentions* Olympic$ in this damn country is lynched. FUCK the Olympic$.
Nathanial, Slocan Valley BC
11/29/09 2:55 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
US Exceptionalism
While I agree that border agents hold too much power, this author is doing a book promotion tour from which she will benefit financially. Sounds like a job/work to me. Why wouldn't she have a work visa? Why wouldn't she be subject to extra screening? You think this would even make the news if she was hassled at the border of any other country? The Olympics angle is unfortunate and a really dumb move on the guard's part, and is really just fluff to the key point of this story - an entitled American got offended that they have been treated like any other visitor to a FOREIGN country.
Dan, Toronto Ontario
11/30/09 11:26 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ed's Note
Hi Dan. Thanks for your comment. The Olympics angle is particularly germane to this story in light of the efforts by various levels of government and the IOC to quash expressions of dissent in the city of Vancouver in the lead up to the games. Among those many efforts is a push to have Xtra newspaper boxes removed from various areas around Olympic venues in the city. Yikes!
Matt Mills, Toronto Ont
11/30/09 1:36 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.