Today's teen films are unrealistic about youth sexuality
YOUTH / 17 Again and Twilight preach abstinence
Kaj Hasselriis / National / Monday, June 08, 2009
Share |

PREACHY. 17 Again, starring 21-year-old twink Zac Efron, is typical of teen films today, many of which promote abstaining from sex until marriage, writes Kaj Hasselriis.
(17againmovie.com)
Have you seen all those magazine pics of Zac Efron, looking bare-chested and stubbly?
 
Admit it. You have.
 
The twinky star of Disney's High School Musical recently turned 21.
 
Goodbye, Tiger Beat. Hello, GQ! Zac's got a butch new look.
 
But judging from his latest movie, 17 Again, he's still peddling the same outdated Disney values. Especially when it comes to sex.
 
If you've seen Freaky Friday or Big, you pretty much know the film's premise. A corporate loser played by Friends' Matthew Perry wishes he could do it all over again and suddenly — PRESTO! CHANGE-O! — he's back in his 17-year-old body, courtesy of Zac.
 
At first, I was encouraged by the film's rating: PG-13 for "some sexual material."
 
Maybe Zac will even get to take his shirt off, I thought — unlike the G-rated High School Musical hits.
 
Turns out I was right. And not only that, I didn't even need to wait. The first frame shows Zac, shirtless and sweaty, shooting baskets in his high school gym.
 
Score!
 
But when it comes to "sexual material," that's the high point of the film.
 
The low point comes about half-way through, when Zac finds himself in a sex-ed class with his teenaged daughter. As the teacher passes out condoms, Zac lectures the students on the merits of waiting for marriage. Having sex, he tells them, is strictly for making babies. Hearing his pleas, the kids in the class tearfully pass the prophylactics back to the front.
 
The rest of the movie is basically a thinly-veiled commercial for Christian family values, as Zac busts up his daughter's relationship (just before she's about to get down and dirty) and then gets back together with his own high-school sweetheart — the only woman he's ever fucked.
 
Boring!
 
And not to mention, typical of teen movies today.


 
Before 17 Again, the last teen hit was Twilight. It's all about vampires, but not the kind who want to suck your ... you know. Twilight is the story of a Dracula clan that cherishes chastity and refuses to go all the way with its human prey.
 
Brit hottie Robert Pattinson, who plays a dreamy 17-year-old vampire, makes it to the end of the movie without satisfying his sexual appetite. The film's sequels, already in the works, promise more abstinence.
 
We shouldn't be surprised: The story's creator is a Mormon who swears she's never even seen an R-rated movie.
 
A decade ago, the big teen hit was the raunchy American Pie, featuring a group of kids who were excited about getting it on. It spawned a host of sequels, as well as a queer imitator, Another Gay Movie (not to mention its follow-up, Another Gay Sequel).
 
Unlike 17 Again and Twilight, those movies weren't preachy. They showed kids making their own decisions about sex and relationships instead of being cornered into one option, abstinence.
 
The Bush era of Christian conservatism is over. Its icky values are finally being discredited. Zac Efron is now legal in all 50 states.
 
Let's quit it with teen movies that show an unrealistic view of teen life.
 
Come on, Zac. Show us what you really got.



Share |


Reader Comments


 
Amendment
Zac Efron might be preaching abstinence in all his movies, but I have to disagree about Pattinson. Little Ashes, anyone? Not a great movie by all accounts, but I like to think that the Twi fans were in for a shock when they saw their dreamy vampire getting it on with another man. Not disputing the crappy Twilight agenda, just the title of the post. Pattinson the actor (as opposed to his Twilight character) is certainly not peddling outdated values.
KS, Tulsa OK
06/08/09 12:38 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Options
As a thirty something mother, wife, friend and doctor I appreciate the messages that encourage teens to wait for (or at least think about) engaging in sexual behavior. I certainly did not agree with the Bush administrations unsupported and unproven tactics but do hope that there is room and tolerance for various sexual decisions. Waiting is not bad. Basing sexual decision on knowledge and thought is not bad. Having the options to make the choices that fit best for yourself and your values is ideal....and for some people that means abstinence. There are a variety of options- I hope that people understand the physical and emotional consequences for whatever decision they make.
T.C., Toronto ON
06/08/09 1:25 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Values
there is no such thing as "Outdated Values". values are values. Just because most people don't follow them doesn't make them outdated. and we shouldn't criticize people for preaching values. we all know that media has a huge influence on teens and young adults, and twilight has already made some people turn towards abstinence. I think we should appreciate that.
zainab, rawalpindi punjab
06/08/09 2:19 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Not a religious issue
I absolutely disagree with the content of this article. There is absolutely nothing wrong with waiting to have sex. With all of the STDs and teen pregnancy, waiting is the wisest thing for a person to do. This has nothing to do with religious values. It has everything to do with waiting until you are mature and responsible enough to handle a sexual relationship and all that comes with it. And remember, Zac was playing a 37 year old father in the film. No matter what a person did as a 17 year old high school student, I would venture to say that as a parent, one would certainly teach their children that waiting to have sex is the best thing to do.
Lilly, USA none
06/08/09 6:10 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Saving sex is good
I also disagree with the content of this article. I believe that these movies are ok for the public and the teens in the world to see. I am a christian so i believe that saving sex 'til marriage is a must. When i saw 17 Again, i really only went for Zac, but when it came to that classroom scene i was happy! It really made my day to see that in a teen movie these days.
Rachel, USA none
06/08/09 7:57 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
teaching teens to value themselves is best
Sex isn't just for making babies its also for expressing love or for just having some fun, all are valid but I think the best thing any teen movie could tell its audience about sex is that its most important for teens, and all of us for that matter, that they love themselves first and that there's nothing wrong with the way they feel with all those raging hormones. I still to this day regret passing up an sexual opportunity as a teen since I didn't think I was good enough, that it was wrong because I was gay, but stressing self confidence and self love love also will help teens resist pressure for unsafe sex and to choose abstinece if they want but to also choose sex if that is what they want. I was filled with so much self loathing as a gay teen I passed up an opportunity to find love and comfort with another gay teen who was much more self confident than me, he got badly gay bashed by my best friends at the time shortly afterwards and then wasn't seen around anymore. I wanted to have sex with him badly, he was dreamy! but I just couldn't bring myself to believe I was worthy of love and/or sex. Teaching teens that they are worthy seems to be the best message we could give teens as a society.
Rich, Toronto Ontario
06/08/09 8:48 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
uh no
How does 17 Again promote abstenance when Zac is a teenage dad in the movie getting his girlfriend knocked up when they were 17?
shorty, smalltown usa
06/09/09 1:47 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Wait A Minute
We'er back to the problems of do we or don't we promote abstance in movies--This subject isn't outdated--I'm a mom , a teacher and an advocate of abstance--Why can that be?---Is it the fact that I've seen the devasation that having multiple partners have on kids lives and young adults--In my own family and my children's friends--Are they happily married? No most are still single and wondering if they will ever commit to anyone--Seeing all the broken lives and broken hearts will cause you to take another look at the precious ones that are infected with the humanistic attitude all around our society--After 12 years I"m still picking up the peices of my daughters and sons "free sex". This isn't a complaint it's a cry to keep sanity in our culture and devotion and love in our relationships--And CUDOS for Zac For making a speech for what's right--No matter what the Media Critics say!!We need someone to stand for whats right!!!
annette weathersbee, leander tx
06/09/09 12:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
This is Xtra
Did the link to this article get sent out to a Christian youth group or something? What's with all the Americans posting here about the value of abstinence? Honeys, you're reading the wrong paper.
A Gay, Toronto Ontario
06/09/09 12:43 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Waiting is not the wisest option.
Lilly, With all the STDs and teen pregnancies out there, waiting is NOT the wisest thing for a person to do. The wisest thing would be to equip teens with a comprehensive sex education and the condoms needed to prevent these ever-so-common risks. Teens will have sex whenever they feel it is right, even if YOU don't feel they are 'mature' enough to do so. After all, 'maturity' is a relative term without any definitive measure. What CAN be measured, however, is knowledge -- and the more teens know, the better off they will be when they finally decide to head out (or stay in) and engage in their first sexual encounter. Whether it be tomorrow or ten years from now. Mind you, a comprehensive sex education involves not JUST the science of the penis and the vagina, which is what I received as a teenager back in 1998. It should also include unabashed talk of oral and anal health, STIs/AIDS, contraception, abstinence as a preventative measure, and an honest look at sexual practices beyond the reproductive, heterosexual bedroom. Yes, I'm talking about things like BDSM sex, tearooms, bathhouses, swing clubs, and prostitution. While it may seem extreme NOW, it is only so because zero lip service is being rendered to such topics when it comes to educating our teens. There is no longer a good excuse for denying that these practices exist since teens will eventually come across them either in person or through the internet. Teens are much better off knowing the ins and outs of these sexual practices as early as possible, instead of leaving them to wrongfully speculate on the subject themselves, or gather unsubstantiated information from questionable sources. It is our duty, as experienced adults, to let teens understand the complexities of sex and sexuality and to let them know that reproduction is not their only option. In short: it is time we start spending as much time educating them about sex and sexuality as we do educating them about history and the natural sciences.
Martin Otárola, Toronto Ontario
06/09/09 4:23 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
to the writer of this article
can you not just enjoy a good film without wanting there to be porn and sexual crap in it? Teenagers dont want to be PRESSURIZED into having sex whether they are ready or not. they want to be encouraged to make their own decision and its got nothing to do with anyone but themselves the reason behind it. if a teen wantS to wait why will they be labeled as freaks and christians living with "outdated values"? i understand the whole preaching thing- its lame ok we all get it. but then why are you doing the same thing except you're just preaching the opposite? the article was discouraging to those who want to wait just like preaching about abstinence is discouraging all the same. You have your opinion and theres nothing wrong with that but let others have theirs as well. cool?
elana, johannesburg gauteng
06/11/09 1:56 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Variety is the spice of life... even for values
I agree with those who say that showing abstinence for teens can be a good thing. However, it should never be the only message. The reality of life is that some will wait, and some will jump right in with both feet. That includes everything we can try from sex to dancing to getting a job. So how can we teach or espouse such a narrow point of view as everyone must wait, or everyone must try it (sex) as soon as possible? We need to provide a variety of views and values and let everyone discover what is right for each one in their own time.
Stephen, Ottawa Ontario
06/24/09 11:19 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.