Harper government can't accept Insite's right to stay open
DRUGS / 'They're basically pursuing an ideological war': Montaner
Jeremy Hainsworth / Vancouver / Wednesday, February 10, 2010
Share |

(supervisedinjection.vch.ca)
The federal Conservative government says it will appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada a ruling by the BC Court of Appeal that allowed Vancouver's safe-injection site for intravenous drug users to stay open.

The appeal court ruled Jan 15 that Insite is a health care facility and therefore falls under provincial jurisdiction.

But federal Justice Minister Rob Nicholson says "this case raises important questions regarding the doctrine of interjurisdictional immunity and the division of powers between the federal and provincial governments."

The site was opened as part of a harm-reduction plan aimed at getting users on the path to recovery, and also to tackle an epidemic of HIV-AIDS, Hepatitis C and overdose deaths.

Though an estimated 1,200 overdoes have taken place since Insite opened in 2003, no one has died.

Insite operates under an exemption from drug possession and trafficking laws. Nurses supervise about 500 injections a day.

Nicholson says the government recognizes that injection drug users need help.

"This is why our National Anti-Drug strategy focuses on prevention and access to treatment for those with drug dependencies," he says in a statement.

January's appeal court decision upheld a ruling by BC Supreme Court Justice Ian Pitfield that granted Insite a constitutional exemption from federal drug laws.

Insite spokesperson Mark Townsend calls the latest government move depressing.

"Every time they take us to court, we win even more," Townsend said. "This is silly."

Insite has the support of the provincial government, says chief medical health officer Dr Perry Kendall.

"It's clearly fulfilling a scientific function," Kendall says, calling the ongoing court battles a federal-provincial power struggle.

Dr Julio Montaner, director of the BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS and head of the International AIDS Society, is more blunt.

He says Ottawa is ignoring scientific research and sabotaging a health initiative for society's most marginalized.

"They're basically pursuing an ideological war on an issue they view as criminal when it has been repeatedly shown to be a health issue," Montaner says. "It's totally unacceptable."

Nicholson says $230 million over five years has been allocated under the National Anti-Drug Strategy for preventing illicit drug use, treating illicit drug dependency, and combating the production and distribution of illicit drugs.



Share |


Reader Comments


 
Insite will prevail
Let the Conservatives logically grind out an irrational fear of losing control over the drugs/medicines people put in their bodies and the freedoms we assert they cannot and will not take from us. Let the Conservatives demonstrate their fawning subservience to US/UN interests. Let the Conservatives desecrate the Charter of Rights and the Rule of Law, our sovereignty, our Commons. Let them treat us as slaves and that's all we are, in their eyes. And let them understand they are ideological dodo birds walking off the back end of their Flat Earth, and they won't have a clue. Give them every opportunity to awaken from their dogmatic slumbers and they'll just snore even louder. This time of mass change is nothing less and nothing more than a patriarchal regime giving way to a matriarchal regime, and making damn sure that the people feel it. Insite belongs to the age we are entering. The Conservatives belong to the one we need to leave behind. Their addiction to punishing people will stop when we stop them, when we outgrow this juvenile need to get permission from them. The government will lose on appeal. Government literally means to control the mind. Not mine.
Bruce Codere, Fox Creek AB
02/10/10 11:24 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
How much money wasted so far?
I wonder how much money has been spent by Harper's government to pursue this crusade against Insite?
Dan, Toronto ON
02/10/10 2:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Harpees/Harpettes
I'm waiting for him to save us from our do-gooding selves by also banning Narcan. He'd sleep better at night then, I'm sure. Harper Eliminates Addiction!
Kate, Vancouver BC
02/10/10 4:32 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
This is a good thing guys
As heart felt as insite is there is there is absolutely no real evidence that insite or harm reduction techniques in general actually work. Most of the arguments they use are straw man arguments that say things like, ''Though an estimated 1,200 overdoes have taken place since Insite opened in 2003, no one has died''. Essentially this means that insite did not harm anyone. That is not an accomplishment and It is NOT the same as saying ''25 people were able to overcome their addictions and lead normal lives.'' There is no solid proof that this actually works. What does work is restricting access to drugs through police enforcement and getting addicts into treatment programs, like drug treatment court in Edmonton.
..., Barrie Ontario
02/10/10 7:11 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
The Tories' drug strategy is...
Remember, kids, if you ban Insite, drug addiction simply ceases to exist! Out of sight, out of mind.
Tim, Victoria BC
02/11/10 1:24 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
statistics
if one criminal activity can be exempted why not any others - discrimination? the rates of HIV and HepC went down slightly when the fixed Needle Exchange clo89654sed in Victoria. one life saved is an emportant statistic.
dbourne, victoria bc
02/11/10 6:33 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.