Fag and dyke companionship
THE WORD FROM JC / Featuring a fag/dyke video mix tape
John Caffery / National / Wednesday, December 17, 2008
Share |

"Fag, dyke companionship, it will get you through /
Fag, dyke companionship, why's it so foreign to you?"

 

I recently had the opportunity to watch the biopic Milk, directed by Gus Van Sant, and I was moved to tears watching the queer community's struggle for human rights. I was surprised at the lack of representation of lesbians in the film's depiction of the struggle for equality. The film gives prominence to actress Alison Pill's wonderful portrayal of Anne Kronenberg, Harvey Milk's savvy campaign manager, but the representation feels token. I left wondering where all the lesbians were, and what a young queer woman would think watching that story. Gays and lesbians have plenty in common, particularly the fact that we have been marginalized for being attracted to the same sex. For this reason, and many more, gay men need to bond with our sisters in the struggle.

The dykes in my life have been quick to defend and protect me. My mother (who is straight) was an incredibly strong role model for me and instilled a high level of respect for women early on. As a child, it was mostly girls who would be my friends, perhaps because I enjoyed skipping rope so much. I have often identified with the female perspective. As I grew up and met queer women, none of that changed. My friend Lex Vaughn and I are planning to make public service announcements encouraging fags and dykes to live and work together. The personality traits are complimentary and fluid because queers often blend elements of both traditional gender roles in their personalities. Lex and I lived together for years and it was one of the best living arrangements I have ever experienced.

I am a man who is attracted to men but that does not equate to denying the equality of the opposite sex. Recently, while bartending at Toronto's Woody's (the gay "Cheers"), I have asked men if they are feminists, and many reply with a "no." I had customers complain that there was a female bartender during the short period when there was one. Men would comment that they could not cruise if women are present, which I couldn't fathom (unless their boobs were so big that you couldn't possibly see past them). The queer west scene in Toronto seems more progressive and balanced. Visits to The Beaver, The Henhouse, The Gladstone Hotel, and the Hump Day Bump nights feature fags and dykes dancing together all the time. I have also seen more meshing in communities that are smaller, where there are not enough queers to be so divisive.



The mainstream music industry that many gay men adore may seem to present a world of women on top because of the idolization of female performers. Gay men have consistently identified and impersonated female icons such as Liza, Barbara, Tina, Madonna, Britney and Beyonce.  How is it that gay men can have such a strong connection to female artists and maintain the genders to be unequal?

In my band Kids on TV I work with Roxanne Luchak, and in the last four years she has been an incredible artist to learn from and she has been a true friend I can count on. Kids on TV has recently collaborated with Yo Majesty, who are an all-dyke rap group from Tampa, Florida. I have been a fan of their music ever since I heard it, and they stayed at my home when they last performed in Toronto. It was the offer to accommodate them that led to the chance to create music together. Now, I can consider those girls my friends and count on them for help. As well, the Toronto DJ Cozmic Cat has remixed two songs of Kids on TV and now they frequently get played at parties around the city. The Montreal group Lesbians on Ecstasy were supportive of Kids on TV since the beginning and often gave us the opportunity to open for them at concerts, as well, they often provided a place for us to sleep when we visited their city. I can only think of the great experiences I have had working with queer women and the incredible outcomes that have materialized.

Brothers and sisters need to stick together, particularly when the queer community is opposed by the government. Prop 8 is a good American example of fags and dykes coming together to fight for their equality during a time when their rights are being taken away. In Canada, if Stephen Harper has his way, our country will continuously become more right wing, and the queer community's rights may be challenged once again. The queer community can be too segregated sometimes — we have to all love, fight and dance together. In the words of Emma Goldman, "If I can't dance, it's not my revolution."

 

Fag Dyke Companionship Mix Tape


Katie Stelmanis - Join Us

Final Fantasy - The Butcher

The Organ - Brother


Hidden Cameras - A Miracle

The Blow - Parentheses


Gentleman Reg - The Boyfriend Song


The Gossip - Listen Up

Antony & The Johnsons - Another World

Dusty Springfield - Spooky


Arthur Russell - That's Us/Wild Combination

Lesbians on Ecstasy - Sisters in The Struggle

The Torrent - Catherine Deneuve

Scream Club & Electrosexual - I'm Going Crazy

Kids on TV - Cockwolves

Yo! Majesty - Booty Clap

SSion - Heaven

Hercules & Love Affair - You Belong

John Caffery & Lex Vaughn Dance Video

Prop 8: The Musical

 


 



Share |


Reader Comments


 
two titties and a dick
What about the trans folk that have helped you along the way? We're all in this shit together.
robbie ridgway, toronto on
12/18/08 4:34 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
more lectures on how to live
What an arrogant ass. Why does Xtra continually run stories by queer males like this author who cannot merely present how lovely their lives are, but who with almost fundamentalist zealotry have to first tell gay men how stupid and shallow or whatever we are and how wonderful and advanced he is. Odd how some queer men's justification for their own discoveries and choices immediately become dogma that they try to blame and shame other gay men into. this whole trip is sad and sick. And boring. And done to death before -- you ran this same article (queer men who love lesbians and woman and hate gay men who sometimes prefer other gay men over lesbians and women -- heresy!) by other and better writers many times before over the years. Are you running out of queer content?
david, toronto ON
12/30/08 12:10 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
World without women
I don't really understand it. If there's one thing you can count on its bitchiness and derision withint the gay community. David's comments are crazy. I read this article and it made me think. I don't think I give women enough of a chance, and I too wondered where all the lesbians were in the movie "Milk". Where were they at Stonewall? But to acuse the magazine of having an agenda because they ran one commentary is stupid. I subscribe to OUT magazine and it amazes me how every month someone, multiple people, write in and say how they've never been so offended and they're cancelling their subscription. It's a miracle this magazine sells one copy. Gays and lesbians need to get it together, stop tearing each other down, and I think this article helps reiterate that. On another note, can we please PLEASE get John Caffrey's article in print? He's a sex god, very eloquent, and I love all his stuff. I just made a t-shirt with his bum on it to wear to the Keith Cole show in January. Give John his props!
Adam, Toronto Ontario
12/31/08 9:31 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Ignore
David is a crank who bitches out on any progressive idea in any article on xtra.ca. Just ignore him.
S, Toronto ON
01/01/09 12:19 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Monitoring the hate
You call it crank. I call it patrolling the boundaries of Queer Stalinism. Gay male separatism is the only way to go. Queer/trans/women's issues do not equal gay men's issues. Never have and never will. Xtra is a Queer paper and I scan and comment on gay male bashing. This article claims that gay men who do not hang with woman are lesser than gay men who do. More gay male bashing. You are so used to it, you don't even see it. Queer is a Gulag. ps gender theory is regressive not progressive BTW
david, toronto ON
01/02/09 10:06 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
misogyny
I'm glad to see a gay white male who's actually talking, thinking and writing about this stuff. I also enjoyed his piece about aboriginal communitites. Amongst gay men, misogyny can come up in various ways. Femininity and effeminacy in men is clearly and generally subordinate to masculinity. Bisexual men are dismissed or erased because of their desire for women. Trans-misogyny (a term coined by Julia Serano) is directed at transwomen by both the gay and lesbian communinties. Once in a while a column or editorial will appear in a gay publication complaining about the acronym and wistfully pining for the days when we were all 'gay'. Sentiments like the above are a reminder to the 'rest of us' that the fairy tale of a welcoming community is just that. If lesbinas, transpeople, genderqueers, bisexuals and people of colour are more visible, that's a good thing. If white gay men like David are threatened by that it's a good thing. And if guys like John Cafrey embrace it, it's even better. I, for one, don't think that gay white men are being pushed out of anything. I actually think that the gay white patriarchy within the Queer community is secure and, unfortunately eternal. When certain guys panic because of articles like the above, it's because the race/gender privileges they're used to are made visible and thus vulnerable.
Adil Mohammed, Toronto ON
01/02/09 5:56 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Historical accuracy
Gay rights groups were started by men and women's groups came later and by that time there were both men and women's gay groups but those worlds were very separate. Lesbian culture is different from gay culture which is part of it. At that time the gay men's groups were more established and numerous and I'm sorry but it reflects reality no matter how much trans and lesbian persons and or their allies would like it to have been otherwise. Also, gay male culture was about muscles and hairy chests and a Marlboro man look with long hair back then and gay male culture has been criticized for years for having a white male bias. that bias exists because white males were the first queers to have the money means or tolerant parents to allow them to not only live openly but start forming clubs and owning discos and porn mags.
Graham, Philadelphia Pennsylvania
02/04/09 8:16 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.