Challenging and questioning racism
GWM
Chris Dupuis / National / Monday, December 21, 2009
Share |

When you're a gay white male, it's not uncommon for other gay white men to try to connect with you through casual racism. Even in the great multicultural capital of Toronto I'm shocked all the time by the kinds of things I hear. It seems as though guys assume that ust because you're pigmentally challenged, you're not going to be offended by this kind of stuff.

When I've used the internet as a hook-up tool, I've found this particularly common. Lots of guys put things in their profiles like "no Asians" or "interested in white guys only" or "looking for European men." I always found the last one particularly funny because it implies that everyone living in Europe is white which I know is false, having lived in Europe.

When I got messages from guys who posted things like this, I would try to open a dialogue about it. "There are lots of Asians in the world. How do you know you aren't attracted to any of them?" I would write. The reply was usually something like "Whatever man. I like what I like. See ya." I eventually gave up, realizing that when someone is looking to get their rocks off, it's not the best time to initiate a dialogue on race politics.

When I moved to Amsterdam this summer, I thought I'd leave this sort of behaviour behind. After all I was coming to the supremely tolerant, open-minded land of gay equality, legal prostitution, and being able to buy hash from the corner store. Surely people here would be as open-minded about race as they are about gays. Turns out I was wrong.

Douglas and I met online and set up a date at his place. We sat in his living room for a beer and some casual pre-shag conversation. "So why did you decide to move to this fucked-up country?" he asked. Kind of a strong opener, I thought. I talked about the various projects I was working on, but then had to ask why exactly he thought the Netherlands was so fucked up. "The government here have lost their minds," he said. "They're letting way too much shit into this country. Too many Turks and too many Moroccans."

Exactly how am I supposed to respond to this? I asked him to clarify what he meant. In the last several decades there has been a large upswing in immigration to the Netherlands from a number of countries, Turkey and Morocco among them. Like most wealthy Western countries, the Netherlands has seen declining birth rates among its younger generation who are much more interested in furthering their careers and enjoying their lives than being saddled with childcare responsibilities.

As a result the country needs immigrants to contribute to their workforce and social safety net, lest the whole system collapse. The problem, as Douglas sees it, is that the government is letting "the wrong kind of people in." According to him, Moroccans are fundamentally bad people who are dishonest, lazy and dangerous, and Turks are only marginally better. As he's going through his diatribe, I'm torn between racing for the door and confronting him about the things he's saying, the whole time thinking it's pretty rich for someone from the Netherlands (a country with a particularly brutal history of colonization and slave trading) to be afraid of immigrants.

I ended up opting to race for the door, mumbling something about feeling like my gonorrhea was coming back. As it turns out, Douglas is not alone in his opinions. As I've met more queers here, it turns out there is a particularly strong dislike for these two ethnic groups in this community. Part of their justification comes from a number of recent anti-gay attacks perpetrated by young Muslim men, including some in crowded spaces and in broad daylight. Members of the Dutch Parliament have called for them to be deported, in part because they fear the negative press will hurt gay tourism.

Statistics on gaybashings are tough to track since a lot of attacks go unreported. Although there has been an increase in the number of attacks in recent years, this may simply be because more attacks are being reported. What is definitely clear is that the queer community in Amsterdam believes that there is more anti-gay violence than there used to be, and many feel that Muslims are to blame.

I understand where this kind of fear comes from, and I have my own experiences of casual racism every time I read about African American preachers "speaking out against the sin of homosexuality" or anti-gay violence perpetrated by Sikh youth in Vancouver. I know how easy and automatic it can be to jump to these sorts of conclusions, but I also know that it's something we need to question. One of the big problems in the discussion of conflicts between the queer community and different ethnic communities is the implication that they are two separate communities. There are queers of all ethnicities; however, the homophobia in their own communities and the racism in the queer community can make it difficult if not impossible for them to come out.

There's no simple answer to this problem, but there are some things we can do as a community to help. Doing outreach to queer youth of visible minorities and creating a dialogue on race within the queer community are a good start. On a personal level, when you encounter racism within the queer community, question it. If a drag queen tells a particularly racist joke at a bar, complain to the management. If you have an online profile, think for a second before you specify that you don't like an entire ethnic group, and never assume you won't like having sex with someone just because they are a member of a visible minority. You may find yourself having some unexpectedly hot encounters with partners you'd never considered before. And there's nothing that brings people together better than good sex.


Share |


Reader Comments


 
thank you
Geez Louise Its about time someone at Xtra wrote about this issue! Thanks Chris! As a gay asian male, I can tell you that racism in the gay community is alive and well, both between races and within races. Modern racism is more insidious and much more sophisticated than old racism but just as hurtful and destructive to the human spirit. It is not an easy topic to discuss amongst friends and social acquaintances but I'm sure it strikes a chord among many gay men in Toronto and beyond. I don't have any quick fixes but seeing it in print validates my experiences and is a great start.
Greg Lee, Toronto Ontario
01/04/10 1:35 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
ignorance vs. openmindedness
I'm a gay caucasian male, and I think surely there couldn't be a quick fix to a problem that's so big... yet it's simple in a way: prejudice is ignorance. Ignorance may be rooted in lack of experiences, and such people will gradually shed their ignorance as they have new experiences. But unfortunately ignorance may be rooted in a close-minded character, and such people will continue producing ignorance in the face of new experiences. The problem is worldwide. As Greg implies in his comment, some Asians hold negative stereotypes about Caucasians. Don't get me wrong; I'm not simply attacking the other side. I have close and intimate friends who are Asian, so, it's not the other side to me. Let's just always try to promote openmindedness.
Bill Holloway, Toronto Ontario
01/10/10 12:26 AM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Complex issue
One of the problems with this particular brand of modern ''racism'' is that there is indeed grains of truth behind it. In the Netherlands example, Muslim minorities are indeed causing violence towards gay people and in Canada various immigrant communities like Sikhs, Jamaicans, Moroccans and others continue to hold on to homophobic and occasionally violently homophobic attitudes. Do some gay people respond to this with racism? Maybe, and that is wrong, but the fact remains that these communities are retaining and importing homophobic attitudes into our country. Why should we have to form a dialog about racism within our (GLBTQ) community? Those various immigrant communities should be getting rid of their old cultural attitudes and values because they are wrong and fully adopting Canadian ideas of equality and tolerance towards not only GLBTQ but also women and other minorities. There is nothing racist about demanding that these groups try adopt our way of life, they are choosing to move here and this is our country.
Mike, Barrie Ontario
01/10/10 12:14 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
Asian"
I agree with most of this article, except for one thing. People who cruise while stating "no Asians" or "no Blacks", to my mind, are not NECESSARILY being racist. You can't program WHO you are attracted to ... some people like fatties, some like blonds. Let me explain. As a teenager,I noticed being drawn on occasion to women even though gay. I realized I was turned on more by Asian and Black women than by white women! But I was less attracted sexually(generally speaking only) to Black or Asian men. Could I be talking about racism here? Not obviously, since for women I welcomed the difference, for men less so. So I concluded that who you are attracted to is not ALWAYS either logical OR a real choice...therefore it seemed to me that "racism" was not the word to use here. IMAGE was, however, part of it. I saw Asian women as (generally)more fine-boned, slim and delicate featured. This seemed to bring out a "protective" macho kind of attraction in me. Black women simply seemed more funky, more sensual. But what about guys then? I believe that sexual preference is partly genetics, but also something more. Almost every gay I knew,when quite young,had invariably been unhappy with their physical characteristics; moreso than straight guys. They could have been drop-dead gorgeous...but still say "my nose is too big". I realized that part of gay attraction was seeing in other men what you didn't think you had yourself. "Oh, if I could only have a face, chin, arms, shoulders, dick - whatever- like so and so." Well, you COULD have them, if you caught the guy and took him to bed! So various physical characteristics became part of the sexual fantasy. However, I had never thought to myself "Oh, if only I could be Asian" or "If only I could be Black". So I think that PART of what becomes our sexual turn-ons is pretty much what we IDOLIZE in
Ken, Paris France
01/16/10 2:04 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.
continuation of last post
PART of what become sexual turn-ons for us are the qualities we IDOLIZED in our formative years. If I had wished I had strong shoulders as a scrawny teenager, it is not surprising if muscular shoulders become a sexual turn-on for me. SEXUAL PREFERENCES have always been MORE than just male/female. They also happen to include SIZE, WEIGHT, HEIGHT, HAIR-COLOUR, and ATTITUDE (hyper-masculine or effeminate, for example). No one would put someone down for preferring leather queens or drag queens to the average Preppy...so why put someone down for preferring one race to another? WHO we are attracted to is NOT a choice; it is firmly hard-wired into our psyches BEFORE we consciously think about it! In the same way, IMAGE again takes precedence in ways that come closer to stereotypes like "small dicks" or "effeminate". Guys who SEEK out blacks could POSSIBLY be operating on the "blacks have big dicks" stereotype. But no-one puts a white guy down for PREFERRING Blacks - even if one of the reasons is because he's a size-queen; if you really like smooth hairless bodies, no-one is going to put you down for PREFERRING Asians. This is not racism as much as simply seeing something in the person which corresponds more precisely to the idealized qualities that we find sexually hot; trying to make this some kind of "racist" political incorrectness seems to be ignoring too many other factors. Of course, I am not talking here about some Southern white cracker who has always hated Blacks as part of his social/political make-up etc. But I think it is totally possible to DETEST racism in every way, and yet be turned on (or not) by one race more than another. People should not have to JUSTIFY what turns them on...
Ken, Paris France
01/16/10 2:31 PM EST
Report this comment to moderator.