Wednesday, November 16, 2011

The slap heard 'round the world

BY ROB SALERNO - If you're gay, odds are you were watching Glee last night, when an amazing Adele mashup abruptly segued into what I'm calling the slap heard 'round the world. Spoilers ahead; you've been warned.

Glee has always been an uneven show that really stops working once you try to find consistency in its plots, or even tone, from episode to episode, or even scene to scene. Just look at how the characters ages change to serve the needs of the plot (Finn was explicitly established as a senior in the pilot episode, and much of the first season was about him applying to college; logically, Puck and Quinn were also seniors then, and last season certainly implied that Blaine was older than Kurt), or how the rules of show choir competitions change every season (how many competing teams there are, what defines their section/region, and how many singers are needed for a team, which was a major plot point in both Season 1 and 2 but has gone out the window this season).

The one plot element that the show's creators seemed to stick to pretty consistently over the past few seasons was its treatment of gay issues and bullying. Once they realized they'd hit a sweet spot with Kurt's coming out, gay stories became a well they kept tapping. And they got some genuinely good stories there, from Kurt's father's evident discomfort with talking about homosexuality despite his general love and acceptance of his son, to Kurt's awkwardness at courting his first boyfriend, to Kurt learning the boundaries of other people's comfort and carving out his own identity (don't whitewash Kurt's creepy obsession with his new brother, Finn).

There was also last week's hugely promoted "THE FIRST TIME TWO GAY TEENAGERS HAVE SEX ON TV" episode, which was also remarkable for being the first time, ever, that two gay teenagers had sex by lying together fully clothed and staring deeply into each other's eyes.

I once tried to have sex with that many clothes on and got a denim burn.

That episode was hugely controversial, so this week they were back to safe topics like hot female teachers having sex with their curiously 30-year-old-looking male students.

 

Of course, the other lie behind that episode was that gay teens had been having sex on Glee since season one: Brittany and Santana. Sure, it was originally just a throwaway joke, but it eventually, brilliantly, became Santana's major storyline. Heck, last season even had a sleepover where the girls talked about all the times they'd had sex together. 

This week's episode brought it all to a head. With Santana finally getting closer to Brittany now that she's lured her into the New Directions' rival group the Troubletones, Santana cranks up her bitchy cover, hurling her usual insults at everyone in her path. Santana's evolved into a mini Sue Sylvester, minus the illogical wackiness that's been grafted onto Sylvester since the writers realized they'd exhausted every logical thing they could do with her.

It's always been clear that Santana tears down everyone around her because she's so insecure about herself, and after an incredibly mean-spirited string of fat jokes directed at Finn, he unloads back at her that everyone knows she's a lesbian and everyone knows she's such a bitch because she actually hates herself more than anyone else and is scared that Brittany doesn't love her back.

The barely concealed homophobia in Finn's rant is more-or-less consistent with Finn's previous fights dealing with homosexuality, including the Season 2 freak-out he had when Kurt redecorated their bedroom. I don't think Finn is a bigot but was instead pushed really hard and found the one clear chink in Santana's armour. 

Shouting "You're a lesbian" down a crowded school corridor until Santana cries isn't the most subtle way he could've handled the situation, but arguably, Santana deserved her lumps. And boy did they come, when one of the students who overheard the conversation passes it along until eventually Santana ends up in a Congressional campaign television ad that identifies her as a lesbian for the sake of smearing coach and rival candidate Sue Sylvester's morals. 

It's an effective scene, undercut only by how ridiculous the entire "Sue's running for Congress" story has been to this point (earlier in the episode, Sue ran ads that claimed one of her rivals is married to a donkey and has a baboon heart). The rival ad is equally ridiculous, accusing Sue of corrupting children by promoting a lesbian (Santana) to head cheerleader and because she's never been married herself.

Sue seems to have learned a lesson about how her bullying has poisoned the tone of the entire campaign because it hurt someone she cared about (just forget the part where last season Sue actually wanted to fire Santana out of a cannon). She should also be realizing that her encouragement of Santana's bullying also, ultimately, led to her confrontation with Finn, which precipitated the crisis.

But before we can actually see the fallout of that scene, we cut to a fantastic mashup of Adele's "Rumour Has It" with "Someone Like You." It's a stunning performance from Naya Rivera, who's gradually revealed herself to be one of the show's best performers:

At the end of the song, Santana slaps Finn, saying that because of him everyone's going to know she's gay. We won't see the fallout until next week, unfortunately.

This episode presented a much more nuanced take on bullying than we typically get on television, particularly from this series, which tends to portray bullies as cartoon villains who stalk the halls to throw slushies at people and demand that the Irish exchange student admit that U2 is overrated. 

 
To be fair, those 15-year-old bullies were born the year Pop came out. Commence feeling old . . . now.

Instead, what we saw were several examples of school bullying and the motivations behind them. Whether it's desire for personal gain (both campaign ads), overzealous competition (the ads, as well as the entire dodgeball scene), xenophobia (when the Troubletones pummel the Irish kid), modelling after adults (Santana), insecurity (Santana), or self-defence (Finn).

There's a rich vein of drama to be mined here. I hope the show doesn't come back next week with the moral that bullying is bad because eventually it makes bullies feel bad. I also hope they can find a new direction for Santana rather than having her turn her bitchiness up to 11 in order to protect herself while hate-singing "I Kissed a Girl" at the male members of New Directions. Or not:

Katy Perry songs are clearly Blaine's territory.

What do you think about how Glee deals with bullying?

Bookmark and Share


Comments

Wednesday, November 16, 2011 4:30 PM

Admittedly I haven't watched all that many Glee episodes, but from what I gather I'm not sure it deals with bullying all that effectively. Like in many TV shows where the subject of bullying is covered, it feels more sensationalist than trying to effectively discourage bullying or raise awareness.

I understand why (again with my limited experience watching Glee) they also portray the point of view or reasons behind the bullying (low self-esteem etc. etc.) but it almost seems to borderline justify it, which doesn't make it any less hurtful to its victims.

On the homophobia issue, I think it falls into that category of "good intents," but creators don't seem to know enough about the full manifestations of homophobia to effectively and consistently comment on it.

Wafflecopters ca


Wednesday, November 16, 2011 5:48 PM

loved the slapped

T ca


Thursday, November 17, 2011 12:57 AM

This episode has hit home for many viewers who are scared to come out.
Finn did exactly to Santana what Kurt said he would never do and never did to Dave Karofsky. Kurt taught an important lesson that using one's sexuality against them is too much. Santana never deserved this and in a real-life situation many teenagers have committed suicide for similar situations.
Glee handles anti-gay bullying well for Kurt and badly for everybody else. I sincerely hope that it doesn't influence anyone to hurt themselves. Glee doesn't quite understand the power it wields and the social implications of that.

Anonymous ca


Thursday, November 17, 2011 12:46 PM

Mr. Salerno please be sure of your facts - not that changes the other content of an otherwise fine article - but it was Brittany, not Santana, that Sue planned to shoot out of the cannon last season.

John P. Sigerson ca


Thursday, November 17, 2011 2:56 PM

Hi John,

Oh I remember that it was supposed to be Brittany. But when Brittany refused at the last minute -- correct me if I'm wrong -- Sue demanded both Santana and Quinn be shot out of the cannon. When they refused, the three of them quit the Cheerios, leaving Sue with no routine at all for the big national competition, causing her humiliating loss.

rob salerno ca


Thursday, November 17, 2011 2:03 PM

I think that whether Glee is handling the subject of anti-gay bullying perfectly or not is actually almost irrelevant. We could argue the finer points of character motivation and justifications for hours, but the simple take-away that Glee is giving teenagers is that bullying is bad and gay is okay.

It's unfair to ask Glee to be a harbinger of gay rights. It's just a TV show about show choir, after all, and not a particularly well-written one. But it is a popular show and I value it merely for having such a diverse crew of gay characters who transcend tokenism. Santana and Karofsky in particular are showing people that we gays are not just about the stereotypes they saw on Will & Grace.

Arek ca


Thursday, November 17, 2011 5:27 PM

why is everyone hating on finn? i would of done the exact same thing santana has had it coming to her, if she wasent such a bitch and a bully maybe things wouldent of happened the way they did. What goes around.........

alex es



Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

The Roundup

Xtra.ca's Roundup
blog is your source
for news and
analysis that has
queer people
talking.

The Roundup is
written by Xtra's
staff reporters:

Rob Salerno
rob.salerno@xtra.ca

Andrea Houston
andrea.houston@xtra.ca

Natasha Barsotti
natasha.barsotti@xtra.ca

and

Adam Glen
Editorial Intern


Log in
Feed Subscribe