Thursday, September 17, 2009

Man, woman or...what?

From our high 21st century vantage point, it's easy to look back on the 1950s and snicker at their cluelessness -- they did, after all, believe that you could defend yourself from a nuclear explosion with this:

And let's not even start on their treatment of gay men and lesbians, who they lumped into a strange, horror-movie-tinged category called...

 

"Society's greatest curse?"  I thought that was Communism!  Oh, I never could keep track of all their their paranoid terrors.  But, to be fair, they may have been on to something with all that "third sex" stuff because it's not like we've progressed much more when it comes to transgender people.  Consider the reaction we've seen to "the pregnant man" Thomas Beatie:

For instance, blogger Jason Wilfong says Beatie "creeps me out" and rants, "Here’s a news flash: real men don’t have wombs. You are not a man, Thomas Beatie, just a woman playing dress-up. Pick a side and stick with it."  He then ends his screed with the tag, "Jason Wilfong of Chicago, believes he has unrecognized genius."  Uh-huh.

But hey, at least he's not driving Beatie to suicide.  Like a lot of us, I've been watching what the press is calling "The Strange Case Of Caster Semenya" with much sadness.  The South African athlete had to undergo gender testing that has apparently revealed her to be intersexed.  Rumour has it now that all the public attention has depressed Semenya so much, she's been put on a suicide watch.

Now I'll admit that this is a problem for a sports ruling board that depends on a strict division between two genders.  But this is an issue that came up in the friggin' 1930s and we are no better at discussing it now than they were then. In the 1950s, people at least considered the idea of more genders; today, conversatives stoke fear about men using the same bathroom as your daughter!!! as a political tool.

The discussions are out there and its up to all of us to get up to speed on the issue so that more people like Rudy can live the lives they deserve.  Yes, all of us -- even gay men who should know better spend a lot of our time policing ourselves and each other for effeminate behaviour, using "queen" as an insult and ranting about being "lumped in" with the transgender community.

How are we ever going to wrap our minds around stuff like this when most of the world still thinks two men getting married is controversial?  Sing it, Chelsea:

Isn't she amazing?  There's still a long way to go for gay, lesbian and transgender rights but at least it's happening...

 


Comments

Thursday, September 17, 2009 1:32 PM

At risk of sounding like one of the ranters you're talking about, I will admit to being confused and uncertain about the whole intersex / trans-gender thing. Our entire society (like pretty much every other society that has ever existed) has acknowledged the existence of two genders / sexes. The interaction between them, and the "roles" and "attributes" ascribed to each have been debated, challenged and (in some cases) changed...but that hasn't in any way lessened the importance of gender to both our individual and collective understanding of the human person. As a gay man, I face some parallel issues to the transgendered person: ie. norms based on gender and societal expectations. Alot of homophobia is rooted in fear of challenging fixed concepts of gender..whether its the homophobia of the religious right ranting about sin, or the internalized self-loathing of the gay community that condemns (or fetishizes) effeminate behaviour. So I understand the fear, confusion and even hate that a transgendered person faces. Part of me feels that on some basic level, gender is a fixed thing, and that "choosing to live like the other gender" is a psychological issue; an inability to deal with being "who you are". And I think "if we allow people ot just choose to be whatever they want to be, where does it end? Is everything up for grabs? Its a slippery slope..." And THAT'S when I hear myself thinking the very things that conservatives and fundamentalists have been yelling at me for years for being gay. I won't say that I'm completely settled on the issue or in my own understanding of transgendered people...but it has given me insight into my own "phobias" and strangely, an understanding of those who have so long feared me.

Daniel ca



Comments are closed

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.0.0

The Roundup

Xtra.ca's Roundup
blog is your source
for news and
analysis that has
queer people
talking.

The Roundup is
written by Xtra's
staff reporters:

Rob Salerno
rob.salerno@xtra.ca

Andrea Houston
andrea.houston@xtra.ca

Natasha Barsotti
natasha.barsotti@xtra.ca

New Comments

Comment RSS

Log in
Feed Subscribe